Huawei in the UK: What it means for Australia and the western alliance


The UK plans to use Huawei â against the wishes of Donald Trump. Photo: Getty/TND
Boris Johnsonâs decision to grant Chinese tech company Huawei a role in Britainâs 5G network could jeopardise Australiaâs intelligence alliance with its western partners.
The UK Prime Ministerâs controversial move to give Huawei the all clear has defied the United States and even some of the PMâs backbenchers.
Wednesdayâs announcement comes just days before Britainâs formal departure from the European Union at 11pm on Friday.
It is Mr Johnsonâs first major geopolitical decision, and it is one that threatens to have far-reaching implications in a post-Brexit world.
So far, Australia, the US, Japan and New Zealand have effectively banned Huawei from its telecommunication networks over fears the Chinese Communist Party will one day use the technology to spy on them.
For years, Washington has been pressuring its European allies â especially the UK â to boycott the Chinese company from contributing to building 5G cellular networks.
This decision has the potential to jeopardize US-UK intelligence sharing agreements and could greatly complicate a US-UK free trade agreement.
I hope the British government will reconsider its decision.
â Lindsey Graham (@LindseyGrahamSC) January 28, 2020
Mr Johnson reportedly called US President Donald Trump after holding a meeting with the National Security Council, which approved the âhigh-riskâ vendorâs involvement.
In an effort to quell fears over Chinese interference, the British government said it would seek to legislate restrictions that would prevent Huawei from supplying any more than 35 per cent of masts and antennas âat the earliest opportunityâ.
Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab also told the Commons that Britain would still have safe access to the Five Eyes intelligence network that includes the US, Australia, Canada and New Zealand.
But many MPs, including former Brexit Secretary David Davis, are not convinced.
Why does Britain want to use Huawei in the first place?
5G is a mobile phone network that promises to deliver lightning-fast speeds. In densely populated areas like London, this technology could be revolutionary.
Huawei is the worldâs biggest manufacturer of telecommunications equipment and is dominating the 5G race.
The Chinese company is about 12 to 18 months ahead of its competitors like Nokia and is roughly 20 to 30 per cent cheaper.
Researchers have already begun developing a 6G network.Â
Aside from the mind-boggling network speed, one of the biggest benefits of 5G is reduced network communication delays.
By reducing the time it takes information to travel to and from your device, futuristic inventions that require a rapid response time, such as driverless cars or surgical robots, could be possible.
5G has the power to change the world as we know it, and wealthy countries like Britain want to get ahead of the pack.
Should we be worried about Huawei?
Yes, but only because of its links to the Chinese Communist Party.
Independent telecommunications expert Paul Budde said Huawei was not a problem â the real danger was the Chinese government.
âIf you look at the social code (the Chinese government) is imposing on the country to keep their people in check, and the way China is using its politics and technology to subdue its own citizens, then of course itâs a worry in that respect,â Mr Budde said.
He said Mr Trumpâs tough stance against Huawei boiled down to Americaâs perception that âyou canât trust the Chinese government and therefore anything Chinese is on the danger listâ.
However, he also said the British government wasnât ignorant about the security risks involved when dealing with a Chinese telco.
âThe Brits are not giving a blank cheque to China; they very clearly limit what they believe Huawei can do without having a security issue with them,â Mr Budde said.
âIt doesnât matter what IT equipment you have, governments and hackers can get into systems. We see these breaches on a daily basis. One day itâs the bank, and another day itâs a university or hospital.â
How could this decision affect US-UK trade talks post-Brexit?
For decades, Britainâs EU membership elevated its importance to Washington as a close ally due to its ability to influence other powerful member states.
But now that Brexit is finally happening, Britain will no longer be seated at the table when the EU makes big decisions.
From now on, instead of turning to its closest European ally, the US will now have to work with other EU member states to influence foreign policy.
The potential fallout from Brexit, combined with the decision to include Huawei in Britainâs 5G networks, might prompt the US to snub Britain and hand it a poor trade deal.
Fergus Hanson, international cyber policy centre director at the Australian Strategic Policy Institute, said âBritain has destroyed its status as a financial hub and all the easy benefits it had from the EUâ.
âNow itâs trying to forge a new independent role for itself, and the first thing itâs done is stick a knife in the side of its most important ally,â Mr Hanson told The New Daily.
âThereâs a way to go before we can assess whether it was good for them to leave the EU, but right now, theyâre not on a good pathway.â
How will this decision affect Australia?
Australia may suffer as a member of the Five Eyes alliance.
âIf you look at the Five Eyes alliance, itâs the most important intelligence network in the world,â Mr Hanson said.
âWhat sits at the heart of that arrangement is trust. These countries have very similar world views and they align on a lot of things, and it creates a body of trust that allows them to share the most sensitive information they have.â
He said Mr Johnsonâs decision to include Huawei in Britainâs 5G network showed that the prime minister âprioritised short-term economic benefits over broader geostrategic interests and national securityâ.
Mr Budde, meanwhile, said Mr Trumpâs reaction to the move could damage the Five Eyes alliance.
âFor political reasons, if Trump really wants to be nasty, then he could start making trouble in the Five Eyes,â he said.
âIf that alliance starts collapsing then obviously that has implications, and the consequences can be quite severe depending on Trumpâs reaction.â
Want to see more stories from The New Daily in your Google search results?
- Click here to set The New Daily as a preferred source.
- Tick the box next to "The New Daily". That's it.







