AFL coaches expect teething issues on holding-the-ball rule tweak

A new interpretation to the holding-the-ball rule will come into effect in round 12. Photo: AFL Photos via Getty
Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell expects there to be teething issues with the AFLâs change to the contentious holding-the-ball rule, but has lauded the move as a positive for the competition.
After weeks of backlash from coaches and fans, the leagueâs hierarchy has directed umpires to shorten the âreasonable timeâ component of the rule.
The new interpretation, effective immediately, comes after some coaches expressed confusion at how the law was being implemented.
âIt shows how quickly you can make a change when youâre really motivated to make it,â Mitchell told reporters on Thursday.
âWeâll all watch the Thursday and Friday night games with a fair bit of interest to see how theyâre adjudicated.
The AFL wrote to Clubs yesterday following feedback over a few weeks regarding the interpretation of holding the ball and how it is being officiated.
Examples were provided to Clubs clarifying one aspect of holding the ball â reasonable time.
Read more: https://t.co/epmfDVPXcN pic.twitter.com/smM0UCm10F
â AFL (@AFL) May 28, 2024
âWeâve shown the players the vision that the AFL has sent and I think everyone will watch the games.
âThereâs going to be a teething (process), whether thatâs players, umpires or coaches working out what itâs going to look like over the next week or so.
âWe all accept that itâs a positive change that needs to be made and weâll see how it goes over the next couple of weeks.â
Essendon coach Brad Scott, who served as the AFLâs general manager of football before joining the Bombers, liked the âproactive natureâ of the leagueâs response to the backlash around the holding-the-ball rule.
âFans, the coaches, the players always seek clarity and when the AFL can provide clarity, that really helps,â Scott said.
âThere will be different opinions as to whatâs holding the ball and whatâs not, and how it should be adjudicated.
âBut all we want to know is what the umpires have been coached on and what the umpires are looking for.â
Essendon had two AFL umpires at Thursdayâs training session to help with clarification around the rule tweak.
âMy personal opinion is that more communication is better when it comes to these things,â Scott said.
âI donât think itâs a rule change â Iâm sure itâs not â but itâs a tightening up of the interpretation of the current rule.â
Mitchell welcomed this weekâs revelation that umpires are receiving in-game feedback from off-field match officials through earpieces, declaring it positive if it is making the whistleblowersâ jobs easier.
His St Kilda counterpart Ross Lyon said he had a âhigh level of comfortâ after previously speaking with new umpiresâ boss Steve McBurney about the communication, but added he was âsurprisedâ to now read it appeared be happening during play.
Want to see more stories from The New Daily in your Google search results?
- Click here to set The New Daily as a preferred source.
- Tick the box next to "The New Daily". That's it.








