Federal Cabinet Minister Angus Taylor is digging in against accusations he used or peddled a forged document and may have acted illegally to score a political point against an adversary.
The Energy Minister has upped the stakes against his accusers, giving an assurance to Parliament he has only relied on information âpublicly availableâ from an official website.
The furore surrounding Mr Taylor stems from a letter he sent to the Lord Mayor of Sydney, Clover Moore, on September 30, chastising her organisation for âunnecessary air travelâ and suggesting there was a âreal opportunity for your council to make a meaningful contribution to reducing Australiaâs emissions.â
His letter cited Sydney City Councilâs âmost recent annual reportâ, which he said âshows your council spent $1.7 million on international travel and $14.2 million on domestic travelâ.
The Ministerâs figures are wildly at odds with the councilâs actual annual report for 2017/18, which listed domestic transport, accommodation and travelling expenses at $4206.32 and the cost of overseas travel at $1727.77.
The $15 million difference between the two versions is astounding enough, but even more so considering Sydney City Council employs only about 2000 staff, many of whom would have occupations requiring little or no travel beyond Sydney.
Using parliamentary privilege, Laborâs energy spokesman Mark Butler has declared the discrepancy between the documents âa forgeryâ and asked âwill the Minister assure the House this forgery was not made by him or his officeâ.
Mr Taylorâs single word answer was âyesâ.
Mr Butler has since challenged the Prime Minister to write to NSW Police asking for an investigation into the alleged forgery and is threatening that Laborâs shadow attorney-general Mark Dreyfus will do so if Mr Morrison does not take up the challenge.
âHe refused during question time to do what the City of Sydney has done and release metadata logs that back up his claim that he downloaded that document from the City of Sydney,â he said.
âItâs a claim that just does not stand up to scrutiny [and] for which he will not provide any evidence.â
In answers to other questions on the matter, the Minister told Parliament the document he relied on âwas drawn directly from the City of Sydneyâs website, it was publicly availableâ.
âI reject the bizarre suggestions and assertions being peddled by those opposite,â he told the Parliament.
If the Ministerâs account is true, it remains at odds with the City of Sydney, which has examined metadata logs of its annual report documents online.
The council has told The Guardian Australia the logs âwere uploaded on 27 November 2018 and not updated after that dateâ.
And the Minister, in briefing the Tele for this hatchet job news piece, told them the City spends $14m on flights and accommodation each year. This figure is grossly inaccurate. Last year, to cover the cost of travel â for our over 2,000 staff â the City spent just over $200,000.
â Clover Moore (@CloverMoore) September 30, 2019
In another answer to Parliament, Mr Taylor added the qualification âIâm advisedâ that the document was drawn from the Sydney City website and it was publicly available.
But if he is in error, the qualification might not save him from censure under the Prime Ministerâs rules on ministerial standards.
It states âMinisters are expected to be honest in the conduct of public office and take all reasonable steps to ensure that they do not mislead the public or the Parliamentâ.
If an error does occur it must be âcorrected or clarified, as soon as practicableâ.
Want to see more stories from The New Daily in your Google search results?
- Click here to set The New Daily as a preferred source.
- Tick the box next to "The New Daily". That's it.








