Court orders X hide church stabbing video for all users


Australia's eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant has ramped up the battle with Elon Musk.
Elon Musk has mocked Australia for âcensorshipâ after the Federal Court granted an injunction against the billionaireâs social media platform X over footage related to the Wakeley church stabbing.
The eSafety Commissioner complained to the Federal Court in a late-night hearing on Monday that X had âgeo-blockedâ footage for Australian audiences instead of removing it.
The court agreed to a two-day interim suppression and ordered X to block users globally from the violent footage pending a further hearing on Wednesday.
Musk responded on Tuesday morning (AEST) with two posts on X, both mocking Australiaâs âcensorshipâ while claiming his social media platform was the only truthful one.
One of the posts shows a fork in the road, with the path to X leading to âfree speechâ and âtruthâ, and the path to censorship and propaganda leading to other social media platforms like Facebook and TikTok.
Tweet from @elonmusk
In the second post, Musk shares an edited version of Prime Minister Anthony Albaneseâs press conference and writes: âIâd like to take a moment to thank the PM for informing the public that this platform is the only truthful oneâ.
On Tuesday morning, Albanese labelled Musk an âarrogant billionaire who thinks heâs above the lawâ.
He said it was unbelievable that Musk was going to court for the right to publish violent content that was against common decency.
Calls have grown for harsher sanctions on social media platforms after distressing footage spread online of the church attack and the mass-casualty stabbing in a Bondi shopping centre days earlier.
Over the weekend, Musk and his company raised free speech and jurisdictional concerns when defying orders to remove footage about the April 15 incident.
The âgraphic and violentâ footage was instead geo-blocked to Australian audiences, meaning it was still available overseas and could be accessed by Australians with a VPN.
The matter landed in the Federal Court on Monday night after the commissioner made an urgent application to suppress the footage on specific URLs.
The fact the content could be accessed by an Australian user via an overseas-based virtual private network showed it had not been removed, the commissionerâs lawyer Christopher Tran told the court.
âThey could have done more,â he said.
It was unclear to observers which particular video was the target of the commissionerâs application.
But Tran described it as âgraphic and violentâ and capable of causing âirreparable harmâ if it continued to circulate.
Tweet from @elonmusk
Footage of a boy repeatedly stabbing Bishop Mar Mari Emmanuel last week could still be easily found on X on Monday night.
The court agreed to an interim suppression that shields the material from all users, pending a further hearing on Wednesday.
A barrister for X had asked the court to postpone the hearing without order.
Given the last-minute application and the time difference to San Francisco, where X is based, Marcus Hoyne said he needed time to seek âsensible and proper instructionsâ.
Granting the order would affect international users âin circumstances where it has no impact on Australia,â he said.
-with AAP
Want to see more stories from The New Daily in your Google search results?
- Click here to set The New Daily as a preferred source.
- Tick the box next to "The New Daily". That's it.








