Health, education should be top of the political agenda

Scott Morrison brought a bucket and mop to his Monday round of radio interviews. The mess he was cleaning up was the implosion at Fridayâs Council of Australian Governments meeting of the governmentâs plan to hand back to the states income taxing powers.
The Treasurer confidently proclaimed Malcolm Turnbull had âcalled the states and territoriesâ bluffâ.
For the Prime Minister, the outcome was âa moment of clarityâ. What was now crystal clear was the premiers â while calling for more money for their schools and hospitals â were not prepared to accept the responsibility or the chance of raising it themselves through income taxes.
⢠Kevin Andrews threatening to divide the Coalition
⢠Turnbull resurrects a Tony Abbott-era slogan
⢠How self-interested senators could hurt the PM
⢠Turnbull starting to falter as election race begins
Both men were finally on the same song sheet. Mr Morrison, like the PM, said having rejected that chance âthey now have to live within their meansâ.
The fact that the Treasurer described last weekâs embarrassing rejection of Mr Turnbullâs short-lived plan âa bluffâ suggests the offer was never serious.
Laborâs Chris Bowen says it was a âmoment of black comedyâ. The Prime Ministerâs office denies it was in bad faith and insists it was a policy hammered out over months.
According to this view, Mr Turnbull only announced it at a sports field because his plan had leaked. Government insiders blame state public servants for this after a recent meeting.
But the messaging from this very messy spectacle is worrying Liberal old heads. What particularly worries them is Mr Turnbullâs statement on Friday that the âfull Gonski, whatever that meansâ is also off the table.
The âfull Gonskiâ, if it means anything, means full implementation of needs-based funding for the nationâs schools and resources necessary to bring all kids up to agreed higher benchmarks.
Opposition Leader Bill Shorten gets it. At the same time he has grabbed onto the Prime Ministerâs apparent willingness to withdraw Canberra from funding state schools.
âLaborâs got fully-funded and costed policies to make sure that every child and every school gets every opportunity regardless of whether or not itâs in the government system, the Catholic or Independent system.â
Mr Morrison tried to mop that up too, saying the states made it very clear those matters âdonât need to be finally determined until into the next calendar yearâ.
Maybe, but that doesnât explain why absolutely nothing was put on the table.
Labor has committed to the âfull Gonskiâ and will use an increase in tobacco tax to help fund it. The Opposition is still to spell out how it will meet the shortfall it claims the Liberals have left in hospitals.
Mr Turnbull on Sunday sought to ridicule Laborâs historic commitments to health and education made in the Gillard governmentâs 2013 budget. He said those promises were a âfantasy â the money was never thereâ.
In a real sense, he is right. In budget forecasts the money is never there. It is based on assumptions. Those assumptions do become more problematic when they go beyond the budget four-year estimates out to a decade.
But they are a statement of commitment.
The Gillard governmentâs Treasurer Wayne Swan refutes the âfantasyâ charge. He points to his budget papers which show a graph for savings out 10 years.
The fact is, these projections are no more or less fanciful than the Turnbull governmentâs own promise to spend $195 billion over the next decade on defence.
There is no doubt Mr Turnbull is playing with electoral fire by singling out health and education in the way he is.
Tony Abbott knew it, thatâs why he promised âno cuts to health and educationâ the night before the 2013 election. He even went so far as to say he was on a âunity ticket [with Labor] when it comes to funding educationâ.
The fact that he broke those promises has landed Mr Turnbull where he is today.
It is fanciful to think Australians care more about the blame game than they do about their health and kidsâ education.
Paul Bongiorno AM is a veteran of the Canberra Press Gallery, with 40 yearsâ experience covering Australian politics. He is Contributing Editor for Network Ten, appears on Radio National Breakfast and writes a weekly column on national affairs for The New Daily. He tweets at @PaulBongiorno
Want to see more stories from The New Daily in your Google search results?
- Click here to set The New Daily as a preferred source.
- Tick the box next to "The New Daily". That's it.








