Q&A: Why limit refugee intake to 10,000, Baird asks
NSW Premier Mike Baird has suggested Australia could take more than 10,000 refugees fleeing the crisis in the Middle East.
To do this, Mr Baird â a popular figure who has advocated for an increased intake of refugees from Europe â urged Australians to give the Federal Government more time to formulate a plan for the crisis.
Speaking on ABCâs Q&A program on Monday night, he said doing so might reveal we could take more than Laborâs proposed 10,000 number.
âThe question is how many more?â he said. âHow do you know itâs just 10,000?
⢠Analysis: PM being led by Baird, Europe on refugee crisis
⢠PM tinkers on refugees as Europe throws borders open
⢠EXCLUSIVE: Government caves in to big businessÂ
⢠Q&A: Border Force visa checks create âclimate of fearâ
âHow do you know it shouldnât be more? And this is my point.
âIt is very easy and very simple to put a number on it, but what can we actually do? Can we do more than that. Who is to say we canât do more?â
Host Tony Jones pushed Mr Baird to specify a number or commit to a total increase quota on refugees from Syria and Iraq coming to Australia, however he would not be drawn into a concrete answer.Â
Mr Bairdâs reply heaped further pressure on Prime Minister Tony Abbott to do more in response to the crisis.
We donât have pictures of them on our TV, but we shouldnât take Syrians over other refugees, says @Bowenchris #QandA http://t.co/bS7WU6rtd3
â ABC Q&A (@QandA) September 7, 2015
On Sunday and Monday, Mr Abbott made commitments to lift Australiaâs intake of refugees fleeing violence in Syria and Iraq.
However it appears that his preference, as it stands, is to only have a greater percentage of Australiaâs 13,750 yearly refugee intake devoted to Syrians and Iraqis. Â
International human rights lawyer Geoffrey Robertson was similarly open minded: â10,000? We should be taking 30,000 at least.
âThe message is no country is an island, not even Australia.
âThese grandchildren of the Gestapo are now the angels of mercy,â he said, heaping praise on Germanyâs response to the crisis in throwing open its borders. Â
âThe grandchildren of the Gestapo are now the angels of mercyâ Geoffrey Robertson on humanitarian principles #QandA http://t.co/J3W2RjjY5h
â ABC Q&A (@QandA) September 7, 2015
Earlier in the program, Shadow Treasurer Chris Bowen pushed for instant action: âWe should increase our intake immediately and urgently.â
âWeâve suggested 10,000 as an immediate intake, and increase our intake and all people affected by the Syrian crisis,â he said.Â
GST is âa very efficient taxâ
Earlier in 2015, Mr Baird suggested the Federal Government should consider lifting GST from 10 per cent to 15 per cent, and on Monday he expanded on the idea.
âWe have pressing needs in relation to our health services in particular,â he said.
âAnd in terms of a fiscal cliff, it is the biggest challenge. If the competitiveness of Australia is maintained, put the balance towards health funding that big expenditure needs.
âYou look after those who havenât got the capacity to afford it.â
Livingstone says itâs important to redesign high expenditure areas @Bowenchris says raising GST is not reform #QandA http://t.co/c9hJM7Bq4o â ABC Q&A (@QandA) September 7, 2015
Mr Robertson then made interjections, taken as comment: âWhy donât you have to pay GST on Viagra but you do on tampons?â
He asked: âWhat about all the promises that the state premiers made back when John Howard introduced GST?
âThat they would take the money and they would abolish land tax, sales tax?â
Back on the debate on the GST increase, Mr Bowen refused to agree with Mr Baird.
âWe are here, Mike, because your PM cut $80 billion out of your budget and didnât even make a telephone call to tell you, and now we are paying it,â Mr Bowen said.
âYou said you would fight those $80 billion worth of cuts all the way and now youâre not fighting them and, you are just saying you will increase the GST.â
âPolitical cowardiceâ prevents euthanasia
Helen Joyce, editor of The Economist, a magazine thatâs campaigned strongly for euthanasia to be legalised, spoke strongly for the practice.
She was prompted by a question from a man with a terminal illness who asked: âWhy am I forced to go through that torture?â
Ms Joyce said: âPeople donât have to do this. It is a human right, we feel, and a choice that people wake and we feel the reason why people arenât allowed to do it is political cowardice.
âThere are places already doing this and it has not led to the sort of disaster that the fear-mongers have suggested it will. These are individual choices.â
Catherine Livingstone & @HJJoyceEcon says we have to talk about dying & Australia supports assisted dying #QandA http://t.co/SPtdNxehSN â ABC Q&A (@QandA) September 7, 2015
The money has to come from somewhere. Why not make wealthy people pay more income tax? #qanda
â Ben Cubby (@bencubby) September 7, 2015
Leadership is being #StrongEnough to offer safety to refugees. (Also genuine tax reform; super, neg gearing, ending coal subsidies..) #qanda
â Richard Di Natale (@RichardDiNatale) September 7, 2015
A politician who says heâll listen to the experts and reserve judgement is a rare and good thing #qanda @mikebairdMP
â Wendy Harmer (@wendy_harmer) September 7, 2015
#qanda We must take more refugees. We can afford it and they will â like all migrants â massively benefit our country.
â Jane Caro (@JaneCaro) September 7, 2015
â10,000? We should be taking 30,000 at least.â says Geoffrey Robertson #qanda
â GetUp! (@GetUp) September 7, 2015
Remember this âcompassionateâ Mike Baird is the same man who said there should be parameters on tolerance for LGBTI families. #qanda
â Jill Stark (@jillastark) September 7, 2015
Geoffery Robertson just WON #qanda: âwhy do you have to pay GST on tampons but not on viagra?â
â Eliza Jane Berlage (@verbaliza) September 7, 2015
Want to see more stories from The New Daily in your Google search results?
- Click here to set The New Daily as a preferred source.
- Tick the box next to "The New Daily". That's it.








