Q&A: Josh Frydenberg slips back in without a fuss

Assistant Treasurer Josh Frydenberg was the first government minister to appear on the ABCâs Q&A panel since Prime Minister Tony Abbott placed a blanket ban on all Coalition MPs from the show in June â but not a word was spoken about it during the program.
This came after a controversial episode aired in June where the ABCÂ allowed convicted criminal Zaky Mallah into the studio audience, where he questioned Liberal MP Steve Ciobo on citizenship laws.
Last Thursday, ABC Managing Director Mark Scott confirmed Q&A would be managed by the news and current affairs division, moving away from the television department, which paved the way for the government to end its boycott of the program.
â˘Â ABC will move Q&A to news division
â˘Â Tony Abbott: âHeads should rollâ at the ABC
â˘Â ABC boss to PM: weâre Australian with a capital âAâ
During the dispute, Mr Abbott had said that âheads should rollâ at the ABC, while Mr Scott had said the ABCâs role of being an independent public broadcaster was âa vital one, central to our culture and our democracyâ, but it should never become a âstateâ broadcaster.
Yet after months of see-sawing, Monday nightâs program went on without a word spoken about the row.
But everyone seemed to forget about the stoush as soon as panelist and former Commander of the International Space Station Chris Hadfield started speaking.
Mr Hadfield wowed the audience with his epic stories of spacewalks and galaxy songs.
An audience member quoted Mr Hadfield as once saying âto fly a spaceship successfully you have to fundamentally change who you areâ, and they wanted to know how he did that.
He created a YouTube clip with his son, seen by hundreds of millions of people across the world, of him on the ISS playing guitar and singing David Bowieâs Space Odyssey.
He said it helped communicate what was happening in space to Earth.
â(We wondered) how do we share (what we are doing)?â Mr Hadfield said.
âYou can talk about the graphs and the charts, but we are running 200 experiments on the station and we set records for science utilisation and we were busy people.
âBut at the same time it is a magnificent human experience, and I just tried to use every means I could think of to try to share that experience with other people.â
No space program for Aus as âwe only have 23m popâ. Canada only has 35m but they manage! More #LackofVision from a useless govt! #qanda
â PollyanaSledgehammer (@HeerKittee) August 10, 2015
Mr Hadfield had the audience captivated as he described the moment of stepping out on a spacewalk.
âLaunch was risky. The chance of death was one in 38,â he said.
âThat the moment comes, you turn the hatch ⌠and you pull yourself out into the universe, and suddenly youâre not on mother Earth.
âAll those things that scare you have a richness that make them worth doing.â
⢠First space-grown vegetables on the menu for astronauts
⢠Astronauts find âanother Earthâ, possibly alive
â˘Â Star Wars-loving astronauts head to ISS
He also suggested that hit movie Gravity, starring George Clooney, wasnât completely accurate, and that Donald Trump âwas a drop kickâ. Watch the Space Odyssey video below.
Former Speaker Bronwyn Bishopâs expense claim scandal was front and centre for much of the opening parts of the program.
News Ltd columnist and co-host of Studio 10 Joe Hildebrand said if you entered politics recently, you wouldnât get the âridiculousâ entitlements that Mrs Bishop will be going out on.
âItâs hard to make these things â retrospective legislation is always a problem, even when dealing with something that the common person would see is an obvious rort, but the rules are the rules and in the case of travel entitlements, it would appear there are no rules,â Mr Hildebrand said.
Letâs get back to talking about space!! #qanda â Tom Cernev (@tomcernev) August 10, 2015
âBut, you know, if thatâs going to happen, maybe we should grandfather it, but certainly for new people coming in, I think.â
Host Tony Jones asked Mr Hadfield if he got a travel allowance while orbiting the Earth and whether it was on compound interest.
âI wish. Iâve been around the world 2937 times and gone above 60 million miles, I wish, but no,â Mr Hadfield said.
But Mr Frydenberg said some people will never be satisfied with what entitlements politicians get and cautioned against wholesale changes to the system.
âIt is really important that we have a sense of balance here ⌠when this committee meets and they make the recommendations to the Government,â Mr Frydenberg said.
âBecause clearly some of the entitlements have been within the rules, but outside public expectations.
âBut I donât think we should seek to change the whole system to the point that it becomes unworkable or unreasonable.â
#qanda is this astronaut related to george clooney? #charisma
â john smith (@da20951997) August 10, 2015
The Assistant Treasurer said the entitlements debate had been a âpox on both housesâ over recent weeks.
âAt the end of the day we need to remember that it is the taxpayersâ money and we as politicians need to use that wisely,â he said.
âThatâs why the PM has undertaken a root-and-branch review of the entitlement system. It has got bipartisan representation.
âI think itâs also important for the public to understand, politicians do spend a lot of time away from home, they are required not just to serve their constituency but to travel constantly, to appear before committee hearings and the like and that does cost money, and I just it is really important that we have a sense of balance here.â
Josh is right. Politicians spend a lot of time away from home. Itâs unlike any other job that has ever existed, in that regard. #QandA â Not Tony Abbott (@notTAbbott) August 10, 2015
Will Tony now make a joke about Anne Summers being around since federation? #qanda #theirABC #nomanners #nopretence â Chris Kenny (@chriskkenny) August 10, 2015
Author and journalist Anne Summers said she understood the need for politiciansâ travel entitlements, but they shouldnât be taken advantage of.
âThese provisions werenât meant to take your family to Cairns or to Perth or to Uluru for a holiday with the kids flying business class. I donât think any of us can see any value in that,â Ms Summers said.
âTo be fair, though, it is very cruel to make children go to Canberra.â
The audience erupted into laughter.
âUnless they go via business class,â Mr Jones said.
âThatâs right. Business class, you want wouldnât to get off the plane,â Ms Summers responded.
Politiciansâ pay should be doubled, and their entitlement should be tested the way tax deductions are #QandA â Julian Burnside (@JulianBurnside) August 10, 2015
Want to see more stories from The New Daily in your Google search results?
- Click here to set The New Daily as a preferred source.
- Tick the box next to "The New Daily". That's it.








