Twitter dominates Joe Hockey defamation case
Treasurer Joe Hockeyâs defamation suit for a âdevastatingâ article published about him last year has begun with a focus on social media.
Mr Hockey has sued Fairfax Media for the âTreasurer for Saleâ series of stories, which his lawyers argue damaged his reputation by leading readers to think he was corrupt â a possible interpretation that âabsolutely devastatedâ the politician.
The articles examined a political fundraising body in Mr Hockeyâs electorate known as the North Sydney Forum (NSF), where members who paid an annual fee were able to meet with the Treasurer at special events.
â˘Â Joe Hockey silent on Fairfax defamation case
⢠âHomophobic prejudiceâ: outrage over Mardi Gras ad
⢠Family âworried sickâ for Melbourne teen jihadist
In order to prove that the article could be interpreted in this way, Mr Hockeyâs barrister Bruce McClintock SC partly relied on social media posts from Fairfax Media itself and from high-profile readers.
A post on Twitter allegedly by former Prime Minister Malcolm Fraser was tendered as evidence, in which Mr Fraser said that using a Ministerial office for fund raising is âcorruptâ.
âHundreds of thousands perhaps thought the Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times were asserting that my client is corrupt,â Mr McClintock said.
Mr Hockey said he was âabsolutely devastatedâ when he bought a newspaper in the Canberra suburb of Manuka last May.
âI saw the front pages. I was just stunned and the newsagent says âWhatâs all this about?â And I just shook my head.â
The Treasurer said his father is frail and there was doubt in his voice when he spoke to him on the telephone.
âHe broke down in tears when I rang him,â he said.
Mr Hockey revealed his daughter later asked if someone was trying to âbuyâ him.
The Treasurer told the court âthe only thing you walk out of politics with is your reputationâŚmy view is there must be integrity in the political system.â
When it came time for the Treasurer to be cross-examined on Monday afternoon, the newspaperâs barrister attempted to use his own Twitter account to defeat the claim.
In 2013, Mr Hockey allegedly posted a message on Twitter criticising then-PM Kevin Rudd for âselling accessâ.
Social media message viewed by over 250,000 people
The articles in the SMHÂ reported the NSF was not fully disclosing its activities to the electoral funding authorities.
A social media message on Twitter with the headline âTreasurer Hockey for saleâ was viewed by 279,000 people.
The court heard a series of email messages was exchanged between the editor-in-chief of the SMHÂ Darren Goodsir, Fairfax chief executive officer Greg Hywood and the political reporter, Mark Kenny.
One email sent by Mr Goodsir in May 2014 read: âI have long dreamed of a headline âSloppy Joe'â.
After Mr Hockey requested an apology, the court heard Mr Hywood said: âBe thankful you are getting what you are. Youâre lucky when an issue like this gets to court youâre not another Craig Thomson.â
Mr Thomson is a former union power broker who was convicted of fraud and theft over misusing his union credit card.
Mr McClintock said the article on May 5, 2014 was motivated by âpetty spiteâ over an earlier apology by Fairfax Media to the Treasurer about a different matter.
He told the court his client had âa spotless reputation for integrity and no-one has ever suggested that he has been for sale beforeâ.
Mr McClintock said the article, banners outside newsagents and Twitter messages represented âa clear allegation of corruptionâ.
âThere is no innocent construction for those words, âTreasurer Hockey for saleâ,â he said.
The case is set down for two weeks but Mr Hockeyâs lawyer told the court the matter may be concluded by next Monday or Tuesday.
I feel after this case MPs are going to start deleting some old tweets⌠Fairfax barrister using them against Hockey #HockeyFairfax
â Mark Di Stefano (@MarkDiStef) March 9, 2015
Fairfax barrister puts forward this tweet from 2013⌠http://t.co/tKBJ5nGGhc #HockeyFairfax pic.twitter.com/cgT1obQjuM â Mark Di Stefano (@MarkDiStef) March 9, 2015
Fairfaxâs barrister Dr Collins is grilling JH over his tweets #HockeyFairfax
â Thuy Ong (@ThuyOng) March 9, 2015
Want to see more stories from The New Daily in your Google search results?
- Click here to set The New Daily as a preferred source.
- Tick the box next to "The New Daily". That's it.








