Bishop reef claims defy science
The Abbott governmentâs claim that the Great Barrier Reef isnât in danger defies all available science including its own, a leading world expert on coral reefs says.
Professor Terry Hughes, who is the director of the Australian Research Council Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies, says thereâs an extraordinary disconnect between the governmentâs position and what scientists across the globe are saying.
He said even the federal governmentâs own reef outlook report, released earlier this year, found the reef was in poor condition and was deteriorating, with climate change the primary threat.
â˘Â Wall collapse firm fined $250K
â˘Â Bomb threat at Barwon Prison
â˘Â Telemarketers caught cheating
Foreign Minister Julie Bishop this week challenged US President Barack Obama over his climate change speech on the sidelines of the G20 summit in Brisbane.
She said her office had sent President Obama a briefing on federal preservation efforts, after he used the speech to warn natural wonders like the reef were under direct threat without climate change action.
âWe do not believe that it is in danger,â Ms Bishop told Sky News on Friday.
âIn fact the Australian government is making every effort to ensure that the Great Barrier Reef is preserved for generations to come.â
The briefing cited a ban on resource exploration and dredge dumping near the reef and the $180 million annually provided by the federal and state governments to manage the reefâs health.
Prof Hughes said he couldnât explain why Ms Bishopâs views were so far removed from the science.
âI think youâll have to ask her that,â he told AAP.
âItâs just not credible to say you are protecting the Great Barrier Reef while doing nothing about climate change.â
He said scientists had also roundly condemned the federal governmentâs recent draft 2050 reef plan.
âThe focus of the plan isnât protection and conservation ⌠rather itâs about sustainable development,â he said.
Deputy opposition leader Tanya Plibersek accused Ms Bishop of insulting the US president.
âSheâs berating the president of the United States,â Ms Plibersek said in Sydney.
âThis is an extraordinarily petulant performance.â
Government support for the development of the vast Carmichael coal mine in the Galilee basin is also inconsistent with reef protection, he said.
â(The mine) will have a Co2 footprint thatâs three times larger than New Zealandâs if it goes ahead,â he said.
âI loved Obamaâs speech. I thought it was spot on. And it really highlights how out of step Australiaâs climate change policy is.â
Professor Ove Hoegh-Guldberg, head of University of Queenslandâs Global Change Institute, applauded Mr Obamaâs speech, adding that coral cover had shrunk by half over the past three decades. Â
He said climate change was one of the major threats to the reef as it increased the oceanâs acidity.
âItâs just chemistry ⌠you canât deny that,â he told Fairfax.
âWe have one of the jewels of the planet in our possession and we should care a lot about climate and he (Mr Obama) wasnât getting that from our leader.â
UNESCO has given Australia until February to show it is properly managing the reef. If itâs not satisfied with the response, the reef could be listed as a World Heritage site in danger.
Want to see more stories from The New Daily in your Google search results?
- Click here to set The New Daily as a preferred source.
- Tick the box next to "The New Daily". That's it.








